Which Medium/light overdrive pedal is best for me?

I'm trying to find a good medium/light gain pedal. I play at my church
if that helps at all (we sometimes cover bands like Jesus Culture,
Elevation Worship, and Hillsong United). I might also use it for a bit
of ambient stuff.

The pedals I was looking at are: Keeley Modded Blues Driver, Fulldrive
2, Timmy Pedal, BBE Preamp, Barber LTD. Which would be best? Or is
there something else that would work out better?